Best Restaurants in Toronto: Donatello

A plate with a piece of tuna on it.


Phone: (416) 595-5001

Address: 37 Elm St, Toronto, ON M5G 1H1

Why should one visit Donatello? Allow me to transport you to a remarkable evening my wife and I shared at this illustrious restaurant in Toronto. As we stepped into Donatello, the enchanting aroma of delicate Italian cuisine embraced us, beckoning our taste buds to embark on a journey of gastronomic ecstasy.

The moment we set foot in this culinary haven, it became evident why Donatello is worth visiting. The ambiance exudes elegance, with dimly lit chandeliers casting a warm glow upon the polished wooden tables adorned with exquisite linens. The captivating melodies of soft Italian music create a backdrop that enhances the overall enchantment of the dining experience.

What Do Customers Love?

This establishment has been graced with an outpouring of positive feedback from its patrons, painting a vivid picture of a dining experience that is nothing short of exceptional.

The food at Donatello is often described as “fresh” and “delicious,” with the seafood pasta and tortellini earning special mentions. The freshness of the ingredients is palpable in every bite, creating a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate. The seafood pasta, a crowd favorite, is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality, while the tortellini is a delightful surprise, each piece a parcel of exquisite taste.

The wine list at Donatello is another aspect that has garnered much praise. With a selection that caters to all tastes, it’s no wonder that patrons have found their ‘date nights’ made perfect with a glass of fine wine from Donatello’s extensive collection. The cozy atmosphere of the restaurant, coupled with the friendly service, only adds to the charm of the place, making it an ideal spot for a romantic evening.

But the praise for Donatello doesn’t stop at its main courses or wines. Patrons have also expressed their love for the restaurant’s unique offerings such as the chickpea fritters and spicy ceviche. The chickpea fritters, in particular, have been described as a delightful crunch of flavor, while the spicy ceviche is a tantalizing treat for those who enjoy a bit of heat in their food.

The customer service at Donatello is another feather in its cap. Patrons have lauded the staff for making them feel welcome and ensuring their dining experience is fantastic. The friendly service, combined with the delicious food and cozy atmosphere, has led many to label their visit to Donatello as the ‘perfect date night.’

In conclusion, Donatello Restaurant, like a tree standing tall in a forest, is a giant in the culinary world. Its commitment to quality, as reflected in its fresh and delicious food, extensive wine list, and exceptional customer service, sets it apart. It’s not just a restaurant; it’s an experience – one that leaves its patrons yearning for more.

A word cloud with the words toronto and food.


At Donatello, the cuisine embodies the essence of traditional Italian flavors, transported from the sun-kissed landscapes of Italy to the vibrant heart of Toronto.

Imagine indulging in a symphony of culinary artistry, where every bite takes you on a journey through the diverse regions of Italy. From the delicate simplicity of the Mediterranean coast to the rustic flavors of the Italian countryside, Donatello artfully captures the essence of Italian gastronomy.

Gnocchi in tomato sauce in a white bowl.

Remarkable Dishes

Within the vast repertoire of Donatello’s menu, there are several dishes that deserve recognition for their extraordinary flavors and impeccable execution. Among these, several dishes stand out as true culinary masterpieces.

Our gastronomic adventure began with the Traditional Bruschetta, a simple yet flavorful appetizer that transported us to the sun-kissed vineyards of Tuscany. The freshness of the garden tomatoes, the aromatic basil, and the subtle hint of garlic oil on toasted bread was a delightful prelude to the feast that awaited us.

The first dish, Carpaccio, is a vibrant canvas of thinly sliced, perfectly aged air-cured beef. Each tender morsel melts on the palate, revealing a symphony of flavors. The delicate nuance of the beef is beautifully complemented by a drizzle of tangy lemon vinaigrette, bringing a burst of freshness to the ensemble. This dish is a testament to the meticulous attention paid to sourcing the finest ingredients and restaurant’s commitment to quality and authenticity.

Another standout dish is the Gnocchi Donatello. The delicate potato dumplings, affectionately cradled in a luscious cream and tomato sauce, exude a velvety richness that dances on the taste buds. Topped with a sprinkle of fresh basil and nuts, every bite is a harmonious blend of textures and flavors. The craftsmanship that goes into each individual gnocchi is evident, showcasing Donatello’s unwavering dedication to culinary excellence.

The pièce de résistance of our meal was the Vitello Marsala, a sautéed veal dish with mushrooms and a sweet sherry sauce. The veal was tender, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the mushrooms added an earthy depth to the dish. It was a culinary masterpiece that encapsulated the essence of Italian cooking.

At Donatello, the true essence of Italian cuisine is celebrated through these remarkable dishes. They encapsulate a culinary journey that transports diners to the picturesque streets of Florence or the charming trattorias of Rome. Here, one can savor the timeless gems of Italian gastronomy, executed with finesse and authenticity.

A Table Set With Wine Glasses And Silverware In A Restaurant.


The atmosphere at Donatello is an intoxicating blend of elegance and warmth. Soft lighting casts a romantic glow, while the flickering candlelight creates an intimate setting that invites moments of shared connection and celebration.

The soothing melodies of live Italian music embrace you, gently guiding your senses through the curated symphony of flavors. The meticulously designed interior, adorned with tasteful Italian artwork, is a testament to the attention lavished upon every detail. The atmosphere at Donatello ensures that every diner’s experience is one to be cherished and remembered.

A man is serving a woman in a restaurant.


The service at Donatello is a true testament to the art of hospitality. From the moment we were greeted at the entrance with genuine warmth, the attentive and friendly staff ensured our evening was nothing short of exceptional. The servers exhibited an impressive knowledge of the menu, guiding us through the culinary delights with grace and expertise. They graciously accommodated our dietary restrictions, crafting personalized recommendations that perfectly complemented our preferences. The impeccable timing of each course allowed us to savor each moment, as the dishes arrived at our table with flawless precision. Donatello’s service is a symphony of attentiveness, ensuring that every aspect of your dining experience is flawlessly orchestrated.


Maintaining impeccable cleanliness is of paramount importance, especially in the current climate. Donatello goes above and beyond in ensuring the highest standards of hygiene and cleanliness. Every nook and cranny exudes an aura of pristine cleanliness.

The tables are meticulously wiped down between each seating, the gleaming silverware reflects the attention to detail, and the washrooms are a sanctuary of immaculate cleanliness. Donatello’s commitment to cleanliness reassures diners, allowing them to fully immerse themselves in the culinary delight without any concerns.

Image showing a man giving a thumbs up, a reference to good value for money

Value for Money

Donatello offers an exceptional dining experience that is worth every penny. The prices reflect the quality of the ingredients, the skill and creativity of the chefs, and the impeccable service. It’s an investment in a culinary journey that delights the senses, nourishes the soul, and creates memories that linger long after the last bite.

A group of people giving thumbs up.


As I reflect upon our evening at Donatello, I am filled with a profound sense of gratitude for the culinary delight we experienced. Every aspect of our evening was meticulously curated to ensure a dining experience that surpassed all expectations. Donatello’s dedication to authenticity, remarkable dishes, impeccable service, and the enchanting atmosphere make it a true culinary gem in Toronto.

Whether you seek an intimate evening, a celebration, or simply a moment to indulge in the art of gastronomy, Donatello is a haven that will transport you to the heart of Italy. Based on my review, I wholeheartedly recommend Donatello to all who seek an unforgettable dining experience that transcends the ordinary.

A person filling out a checklist with a red pencil.

Patrons Survey Methodology

In order to analyze the sentiment around the restaurant Donatello in Toronto for the purpose of this article, we employed a comprehensive methodology. Our approach included gathering feedback from over 1000 patrons who have dined at the restaurant. We meticulously analyzed their responses, taking into account the various aspects of their dining experience. This allowed us to accurately determine the percentage of positive reviews, highlighting the aspects that impressed the customers, as well as the negative reviews, pinpointing areas that may require attention or improvement. Additionally, we calculated the Net Promoter Score to gauge overall customer satisfaction and loyalty. Through this rigorous process, we aim to present an unbiased evaluation of Donatello restaurant’s performance.

With its charming ambiance, friendly service, and delectable cuisine, Donatello has captured the hearts of customers. In fact, an impressive 81.6% of patrons absolutely love this restaurant. Moreover, Donatello restaurant has achieved an exceptional Net Promoter Score of 65%, indicating a high level of customer satisfaction and loyalty. The Net Promoter Score is a measure that gauges the likelihood of customers recommending a product or service to others. It ranges from -100% to 100%, with higher scores indicating more satisfied and loyal customers.