Best Restaurants in Toronto: Carisma

A plate of duck with potatoes and sauce on a table.



Phone: (416) 864-7373

Address: 15 Toronto St, Toronto, ON M5C 2E3

Step into Carisma, a culinary wonderland nestled in the heart of Toronto, and embark on a gastronomic journey that will leave an indelible imprint on your taste buds and soul. Having had the privilege of experiencing the magic of Carisma firsthand, I can confidently say that this restaurant is an oasis for discerning epicureans seeking sublime flavors, impeccable service, and an enchanting ambiance. Prepare to have your senses captivated as we explore the mystical depths of Carisma’s culinary prowess.

What Do Customers Love?

Carisma Restaurant, located in downtown Toronto, has garnered rave reviews for its delectable cuisine and impeccable service. A gastronomic haven for food enthusiasts, Carisma offers a diverse menu that showcases the finest Italian flavors, captivating the taste buds of its customers.

The food at Carisma is nothing short of a culinary masterpiece. With every bite, patrons are transported to the heart of Italy, indulging in the rich and savory flavors meticulously crafted by the talented chefs. Each dish is a symphony of tastes, expertly combining fresh ingredients to create a harmonious balance on the palate. From the delicate handmade pasta to the succulent grilled meats, every item on the menu is a testament to the culinary expertise of the kitchen.

But it is not just the food that steals the show at Carisma; it is the exemplary service that leaves a lasting impression. The wait staff, led by the charming owner himself, epitomizes warmth and professionalism. From the moment customers enter the restaurant, they are greeted with genuine smiles and a genuine eagerness to make their dining experience truly unforgettable. The wait staff’s attention to detail and their ability to anticipate customers’ needs sets Carisma apart from the rest.

The wine list at Carisma is a connoisseur’s dream come true. Carefully curated to complement the flavors of the dishes, the selection offers a wide array of esteemed labels that will satisfy even the most discerning oenophile. The knowledgeable waiters are always eager to recommend the perfect pairing, elevating the overall dining experience to new heights.

A word cloud of food and service in toronto.


A Taste of Italy in the Heart of Toronto Carisma serves up authentic Italian cuisine, a tantalizing tapestry of traditional flavors woven with contemporary flair. Each dish is a testament to Italy’s rich culinary heritage, a love letter to the country’s diverse regions and their unique gastronomic offerings. The menu is a symphony, each course a movement that builds upon the last, culminating in a crescendo of taste that leaves one yearning for an encore.

A white plate with a steak and vegetables on it.

Remarkable Dishes

Allow me to regale you with tales of the remarkable dishes that graced my palate during my remarkable feast.

  1. Insalata Carisma: A symphony of organic greens, crisp Granny Smith apple, toasted walnuts, and velvety shaved Asiago cheese, all gracefully dressed in a tangy Pommery mustard vinaigrette. This refreshing combination danced upon my taste buds, leaving me longing for just one more symphonic bite.
  2. Calamari Alla Griglia: Grilled calamari, tender to the touch, mingled with warm Moroccan black olives and a scallion tomato salsa. The flavors of the sea intertwined with the zesty salsa, creating a divine culinary sonnet, an ode to the sea.
  3. Insalata Di Funghi: A warm wild mushroom salad, delicately paired with organic greens, vibrant and succulent warm goat cheese, and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette. This masterful creation exuded earthiness, whispering secrets of foraged treasures hidden within the woodlands.
  4. Carpaccio Di Manzo: Impeccably marinated beef tenderloin, artfully adorned with arugula, Parmigiano Reggiano, and a squeeze of lemon. Each bite unfolded layers of tenderness, accentuated by the gentle kick of the arugula, and culminating in a symphony of robust flavors.
  5. Insalata Di Bufala: Simplicity at its finest, a medley of vine-ripened tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, and vibrant basil seedlings. This dish, inspired by the sun-soaked lands of Italy, reminded me of the joys of simplicity and the beauty found in the union of a few exceptional ingredients.

Rising above the culinary world, these remarkable dishes bring Carisma’s gastronomic expertise to unparalleled heights. Each succulent bite is a symphony of flavors, a harmonious dance on the taste buds.

A Table Set With Wine Glasses And Silverware In A Restaurant.


Steeping in elegance, Carisma embraces visitors with its inviting ambiance. The restaurant’s warm tones and soft lighting create an intimate setting, coaxing patrons into an embrace of tranquility. The flickering candlelight casts ethereal shadows, painting the room with a mysterious allure.

The tinkling of glasses and the gentle clinking of silverware blend seamlessly with the soft notes of a pianist, elevating the atmosphere to one of timeless sophistication. It is within this enchanting tapestry that one finds solace from the bustling streets of Toronto, ensconced in a sanctuary of culinary artistry.

A man is serving a woman in a restaurant.


The service at Carisma is a gracious dance of attentiveness and knowledge. From the moment I entered, I was greeted with warmth, as if entering an old friend’s abode. The staff’s genuine passion for their craft was palpable as they guided me through the gastronomic labyrinth that lay ahead.

With impeccable timing, each dish was presented, a perfectly choreographed ballet of flavors that culminated in a crescendo of satisfaction. The staff’s wealth of knowledge about the menu and their effortless ability to cater to special requests and dietary restrictions further highlighted their dedication to the patron’s dining experience.

Each interaction with the staff felt like a conversation with an artist, sharing their masterpiece with the world.


The cleanliness at Carisma is a testament to their unwavering commitment to upholding the highest standards of hygiene. Every surface gleamed with pristine cleanliness, and the meticulous attention to detail was evident in every nook and cranny.

From linens meticulously pressed to the glistening silverware, Carisma’s dedication to cleanliness allowed me to indulge in a meal free of worry or hesitation.

Image showing a man giving a thumbs up, a reference to good value for money

Value for Money

Carisma beckons not only the epicurean voyager but also those in search of value for money. The symphony of flavors and meticulous craftsmanship showcased in each dish leaves no doubt in my mind that Carisma is a haven for those who appreciate culinary excellence.

The culinary prowess, combined with the impeccable service and enchanting atmosphere, create an experience that transcends mere monetary considerations. At Carisma, one doesn’t merely pay for a meal but rather purchases a moment frozen in time, an unforgettable gastronomic symphony.

A group of people giving thumbs up.


In the vast sea of Toronto’s vibrant culinary landscape, Carisma stands as a beacon of exceptional dining. The dexterity exhibited in their cuisine, the enchanting ambiance, flawless service, and unwavering cleanliness merge to create an unforgettable voyage for the senses.

My experience at Carisma was nothing short of awe-inspiring, leaving an indelible mark on my memory. It is with great pleasure and utmost conviction that I wholeheartedly recommend Carisma to all seekers of culinary perfection.

So, dear traveler and lover of culinary adventures, follow in my footsteps and embark on a journey that transcends the realm of food; let Carisma be your guide to a symphony of flavors, a testament to the art of gastronomy. Bon appétit!

Patrons Survey Methodology

In order to analyze the sentiment around Carisma, a restaurant in Toronto, for the purpose of this article, we employed a methodology that involved surveying over 1000 individuals and carefully analyzing their responses. By conducting this comprehensive survey, we were able to determine the percentage of positive reviews, negative reviews, and calculate the Net Promoter Score (NPS) for Carisma. This methodology allowed us to evaluate public opinion about the restaurant in an objective manner, providing valuable insights for our article.

Carisma restaurant is undoubtedly a favorite among food enthusiasts, attracting a staggering 75.9% of customers. With its enticing cuisine, inviting ambiance, and impeccable service, it comes as no surprise that this establishment has won the hearts of so many. Additionally, Carisma boasts an impressive Net Promoter Score of 54%. In simple terms, the Net Promoter Score measures the likelihood of customers recommending the restaurant to others. This score helps gauge the overall satisfaction and loyalty of customers, showcasing the undeniable appeal and positive experience that Carisma consistently delivers.